Lizza & Carullo CPAs & Advisors

Understanding Tax Deduction Opportunities for Scam-Induced Losses

For many business owners navigating the intricate landscape of tax laws, understanding deductions associated with scam-related losses is crucial. Recent changes in tax regulations have shifted the focus of casualty and theft loss, now predominantly limiting such deductions to disaster-associated incidents. However, if you've been deceived in a scam, certain tax strategies can still play a pivotal role in reclaiming lost money.

Previously, tax law permitted deductions for theft losses not covered by insurance. While amendments have curtailed this to focus on disaster-related incidents, a crucial exception remains for those who suffered losses in transactions intended for profit. This niche avenue for deduction can often fly under the radar but is significant for those who qualify under the Internal Revenue Code Section 165(c)(2).

This section provides for taxpayers whose financial losses occurred through profit-driven activities, offering a tax relief lifeline even without a disaster declaration. Understanding this provision can help you recuperate some financial relief from the monetary distress caused by scams.

Key Eligibility for Profit-Motivated Losses: To qualify these loss deductions, specific criteria need to be met:

  1. Profit Motive: The transaction must primarily aim for economic gain. Documented evidence of a bona fide profit expectation—substantiated through case law and IRS rulings—is crucial.

  2. Transaction Type: Eligible transactions involve investment activities like securities, real estate, or other income-generating pursuits. Personal or social activities do not qualify.

  3. Loss Nature: The loss must be directly tied to a transaction aimed at profit, demonstrated clearly in your financial and legal documentation.

An analysis of recent IRS guidance further clarifies what scenarios qualify for these deductions. Image 2

Examples of Deductible Events: Consider these scenarios:

  • Investment Scams: Losses from deceitful schemes are deductible if profits were the original motivation. Ensure thorough documentation of transaction legitimacy and expectations of profit.
  • Theft Losses: These must emerge from genuinely profit-focused transactions, not from personal or sentimental motivations.

Gain Year-Round Financial Clarity and Confidence
Partner with Lizza & Carullo CPAs & Advisors for ongoing guidance, proactive tax planning, and strategic financial support. Whether you’re growing a business or navigating personal taxes, our year-round advisory approach helps you stay organized, tax-efficient, and in control — with a team that’s here when you need us, not just at tax time.
Schedule Your Discovery Call

Negative Tax Consequences: Scams involving retirement accounts—such as IRAs—can have various tax implications depending on the account type.

For traditional IRAs, funds prematurely withdrawn due to scams are taxable income, potentially increasing your tax bracket and incurring an early withdrawal penalty. In contrast, Roth IRAs, funded with after-tax contributions, offer a different outlook. Withdrawals, if compliant with regulations, often face no immediate tax liabilities Image 3

Here are clearer examples indicating when a scam-related loss qualifies as a casualty loss:

Example 1: Financial Advisor Scam - Qualified Personal Casualty Loss

A taxpayer deceived by an impersonator claiming to be a fraud specialist intended to protect and reinvest funds, forming a profit-driven motive. Such actions, documented properly, qualify for a theft loss deduction.

  • If able to itemize deductions, losses appear in Schedule A, though traditional IRA distributions remain taxable, alongside any potential early distribution penalties.
Example 2: Romance Scam - Unqualified Personal Casualty Loss

Another taxpayer transferred funds following a fabricated personal appeal without a profit motive. The absence of investment intent deems these losses non-deductible, illustrating the pivotal role motive plays in qualifying under Section 165(c)(3).

Documentation supporting intent is imperative, particularly with investment endeavors, to showcase legitimacy and eschew scrutiny under IRS compliance protocols.

At our firm, Lizza Carullo CPAs & Advisors, we underscore the importance of financial vigilance against scams. Proactivity and education, especially for vulnerable populations like the elderly, are invaluable safeguards against financial deceit. We offer guidance on fraud detection and prevention, an essential component of maintaining secured financial health.

Gain Year-Round Financial Clarity and Confidence
Partner with Lizza & Carullo CPAs & Advisors for ongoing guidance, proactive tax planning, and strategic financial support. Whether you’re growing a business or navigating personal taxes, our year-round advisory approach helps you stay organized, tax-efficient, and in control — with a team that’s here when you need us, not just at tax time.
Schedule Your Discovery Call
Share this article...
Facebook
Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Pocket Reddit Email

Want tax & accounting tips and insights?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .
Lizza & Carullo CPAs & Advisors Smart tax and advisory support for your business and personal finances.
Welcome to the Lizza & Carullo CPABot. I can help you learn about our Business Advisory Programs, year-round personal tax planning, how to work with our team, and how to schedule a Discovery Call. What would you like to do today?
Please fill out the form and our team will get back to you shortly The form was sent successfully
Find Directions
Meet with our CPAs